Conversational AI in Education: Which Chatbot is Best for Teachers and Students?
Ever wished you had an assistant to give your students that extra nudge, helping them master tough concepts at their own pace while supporting your teaching?
That’s where conversational AI steps in.
Conversational AI acts as a teacher’s sidekick, seamlessly integrating into classroom routines to guide students through personalized, interactive self-study sessions.
With so many options out there, we’re diving into the top AI tutors to see which one’s the best fit for self-practice and teaching, comparing customization, applications, accuracy, ease, privacy, and cost, perfect for those searching for the “best conversational AI for teachers” or “AI tutor.”
Exploring The Market Of AI Tutors
The AI tutor market is a vibrant ecosystem, with each tool offering unique strengths to transform learning.
Google Gems, a recent addition to Google’s Gemini in Classroom, lets teachers create AI study helpers from Google Workspace materials, making it ideal for schools already using Google’s ecosystem, though it leans more toward self-study (includes a premade Learning Coach Gem, designed to assist with self-study) than dynamic classroom interactions.
Gemini Chatbot
MagicSchool Custom Chatbot, part of MagicSchool’s 80+ education-focused tools, enables teachers to build chatbots from classroom resources for self-study Q&A or role-playing scenarios, like interacting with a historical figure, with a strong emphasis on AI literacy.
MagicSchool Custom Chatbot
SchoolAI Spaces provides customizable AI-powered Sidekick for personalized self-study or classroom interactions, such as Q&A with historical figures, prioritizing safety and teacher oversight.
School AI Sidekick
Redmenta’s Chatbot is a teacher-driven tool that uses uploaded lesson materials to ensure curriculum-aligned responses, offering four modes: Explainer for clarifying concepts, Quiz for test prep, Role-Playing for practical skills like language practice and Custom Prompt for creative lessons, making it the most versatile chatbot for both solo study and classroom engagement.
On Redmenta Chatbot teachers could choose from different modes
Redmenta Chatbot in action
Comparing Strengths and Features
How much control do teachers have?
MagicSchool’s Custom Chatbot: Teachers can create chatbots from documents for study questions or class role-playing, offering flexibility within its broader toolkit.
Google Gems: Allows customization within Google Classroom resources but lacks diverse classroom interaction modes.
SchoolAI Spaces: Supports topic-specific chats for self-study or class but offers fewer interaction options.
Redmenta: Provides the most control, using uploaded materials with four modes—adaptive quizzes, explainer, role-playing, and a Custom Prompt Mode for unique lessons. Complete teacher control through behavior settings, topic management, and conversation rules ensures tailored learning experiences.
Customization is key: AI tutors like Redmenta give teachers unparalleled control to craft unique lessons, from adaptive quizzes to role-playing scenarios.
Can they keep students engaged?
MagicSchool: Captivates with self-study Q&A and classroom role-playing that bring lessons to life.
Google Gems: Solid for self-study with tools like “Study Partner” or “Quiz Me,” but less engaging for classroom use.
SchoolAI Spaces: Offers engaging chats for study and activities like career exploration but has fewer modes.
Redmenta: Excels with Explainer simplifying concepts, Quiz adjusting to student pace, and Role-Playing building skills for real-world scenarios. The specialized learning modes are built for diverse educational goals like critical thinking, problem-solving, and creative exploration.
Engagement drives learning: tools like MagicSchool and Redmenta make lessons pop with interactive Q&A and real-world role-playing.
Are their responses accurate?
MagicSchool: Uses document-based responses for reliability, monitored via Student Room Insights.
Google Gems: Relies on selected resources, but the Gemini model may falter in self-study without classroom oversight.
SchoolAI Spaces: Ensures accuracy with moderated content.
Redmenta: Sticks to teacher-provided materials to minimize errors, with teacher reviews ensuring top accuracy.
Accuracy matters: Redmenta and MagicSchool ensure reliable responses by sticking to teacher-provided materials.
How easy are they to use?
MagicSchool: User-friendly within its dashboard, integrates with Google Classroom and Canvas.
Google Gems: Seamless for Google Workspace users but less effective outside that ecosystem.
SchoolAI Spaces: Simple to set up with LMS support for quick adoption.
Redmenta: Intuitive and compatible with learning management systems for ease of use.
Ease of use empowers teachers: intuitive platforms like SchoolAI and Redmenta integrate seamlessly with existing LMS systems.
How well do they support student evaluation?
MagicSchool: Tracks progress with real-time analytics via Student Room Insights for study and role-playing tasks.
Google Gems: Offers basic quiz feedback, limited by minimal analytics.
SchoolAI Spaces: Provides chat log insights for engagement and understanding, but lacks depth.
Redmenta: Delivers flexible evaluation through rubric-based assessment, teacher comments, full conversation review, and adaptive quizzes that regulate topic abandonment, ensuring precise, focused feedback.
Evaluation drives progress: Redmenta’s comprehensive evaluation tools lead, followed by MagicSchool’s real-time analytics.
Are they safe for students?
MagicSchool: FERPA/COPPA-compliant with a 93% privacy rating and monitoring features.
Google Gems: Avoids data training without consent, making it safe for K-12 environments.
SchoolAI Spaces: Offers high security with safety alerts for student interactions.
Redmenta: GDPR-compliant with content filters and chat reviews, suitable for all ages.
Safety first: GDPR and FERPA/COPPA compliance ensure tools like Redmenta and MagicSchool protect student data.
Summary
Conversational AI tutors can support teachers by personalizing learning and guiding students. But without evaluation, chatbots like ChatGPT can weaken critical thinking and memory, as shown by MIT research [Kosmyna et al., 2025]. Evaluation is critical to keep minds sharp, with feedback driving growth, though AI-specific studies are still needed in the future [Hattie & Timperley, 2007].
Redmenta stands out with unique strengths in material-based reliability, specialized learning modes, complete teacher control, a safe learning environment, and flexible evaluation tools, offering robust assessments to track progress. MagicSchool excels in engagement and analytics, while SchoolAI Spaces and Google Gems trail in evaluation depth.
Feature
MagicSchool
Google Gems
SchoolAI
Redmenta
Customization
Strong: Builds chatbots from documents for self-study or role-playing, flexible but tied to MagicSchool’s toolkit.
Good: Customizes using Google Classroom resources for self-study tasks but limited in classroom versatility.
Moderate: Creates topic-specific chats for self-study or class but fewer interaction modes.
Strong: Uploads teacher materials for precise curriculum alignment; six modes (Explainer, Quiz, Role-Playing, Custom Prompt) offer unmatched flexibility for self-study and class.
Engagement
Strong: Offers self-study Q&A and classroom role-playing (e.g., historical figures).
Moderate: Solid for self-study with “Study Partner” or “Quiz Me” but basic for classroom use, tied to Google Classroom.
Moderate: Engaging chats for study and class activities (e.g., career exploration) but less varied.
Strong: Excels in self-study with Explainer clarifying concepts, Quiz adapting to pace, and Role-Playing building skills.
Accuracy
Strong: Document-based for accuracy, with Student Room Insights monitoring, close to Redmenta.
Fair: Relies on selected resources; Gemini model may falter in self-study, with less classroom oversight.
Strong: Document-based for accuracy, with Student Room Insights monitoring, close to Redmenta.
Strong: Uses materials uploaded by the teacher to avoid errors, with teacher review for top reliability in self-study and class.
Ease of Use
Strong: User-friendly in MagicSchool’s dashboard, integrates with Google Classroom/Canvas.
Strong: Seamless for Google Workspace users, less effective outside.
Strong: Simple setup with LMS support for self-study and class.
Strong: Intuitive, standalone, LMS-compatible; custom modes need minor setup but highly flexible.
Evaluation
Fair: Tracks progress with real-time analytics via Student Room Insights.
Moderate: Basic feedback, limited by minimal analytics.
Fair: Chat log insights for engagement, but lacks depth.
Strong: Delivers flexible evaluation through rubric-based assessment, teacher comments, full conversation review, and adaptive quizzes.
Privacy
Strong: FERPA/COPPA-compliant, 93% privacy rating, with monitoring.
Strong: No data training without consent, K–12 safe.
Strong: High security with safety alerts for issues like bullying.
Strong: GDPR-compliant, with content filtering and chat reviews, ideal for all ages.
References:
Kosmyna, N., et al. (2025). Your Brain on ChatGPT: Accumulation of Cognitive Debt when Using an AI Assistant for Essay Writing Task. MIT Media Lab. https://www.media.mit.edu/publications/your-brain-on-chatgpt-accumulation-of-cognitive-debt-when-using-an-ai-assistant-for-essay-writing-task/
Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The Power of Feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77(1), 81–112. https://doi.org/10.3102/003465430298487
July 25, 2025
Join our teacher community
Connect with open-minded educators, gain access to ongoing support from the AI experts of Redmenta, and discover a wealth of interesting learning resources.
.png)
.png)
